Its so easy to point fingers.
Banks. The government. Local politicians / mayors. The real estate industry. The housing industry. Greedy sellers.
Canada’s housing market has been relatively stable for over a decade, with the notable exception of Toronto and Vancouver which are the country’s hottest real estate markets. As Canada’s largest city Torono's home prices have risen 10.5% over the past year alone. The condo industry in Toronto is so hot that there is now three times as many cranes dotting Toronto’s skyline as there are in New York City.
Many real estate analysts are becoming increasingly worried that Toronto, Vancouver and Calgary are in an American-style housing bubble which could lead to an implosion of prices and a recession.
The analysts are not alone. Bank of Canada Governor Mark Carney is sounding the alarm over the growing level of household debt, while maintaining the overnight lending interest rate at a near-record low level of 1%. Mark Carney's hands are a bit tied in this matter. He can't raise interest rates without risking being the needle which bursts the bubble.
What is bizarre is the economy in Toronto and Vancouver are both stagnant and yet the prices are rising unusually fast. In contrast cities like Edmonton and Saskatoon where the economy is booming but home prices are stable.
Some people argue that the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation’s (CMHC) policies are to blame because they encourage overseas investment in Canadian real estate. They claim that investors from overseas have corrupted the system and is creating an artificial and potentially dangerous real estate bubble that will ultimately lead to a recession in Canada.
There is of course a quick and easy solution to this. Ban overseas investors from buying homes and condos in Canada.
The CMHC controls the majority of Canada's mortgage insurance and securitization markets and guarantees all (100%) of the principle balances and interest rates on insured residential mortgages.
The problem is that the Bank of Canada has such low interest rates that in combination foreign investment and low interest rates in causing the bubble to grow at an exponential rate. Investors are particularly attracted to Toronto and Vancouver's markets because of the recent history of rising housing prices.
The longer interest rates remain low and investors keep flooding the real estate bubble the worst it will be when the bubble bursts and a market correction takes place.
Trying to prevent a correction however might make foreign investors skittish and cause them to withdraw from the Canadian real estate market in a hurry. Thus a preventive measure could even kickstart the market correction.
Foreign investors are not wholly responsible for creating Canada's housing bubble. Investors are sheep. They go where they see a financial opportunity with little risk.
Foreign investment is normally a good thing. It creates jobs and adds to the local economy. More condos and homes being built means more money for developers and construction works. More rental properties become available. The problem however is that investors have a tendency to flood markets. The home prices and rental prices go up, people get into household debts they cannot afford due to outrageous mortgages... and when the fit hits the shan everyone with a mortgage loses their shirts.
So who does the bulk of the blame lay with then? The answer is the blame can be placed squarely on government policy.
By guaranteeing 100% of CMHC-insured mortgages and 90% of privately insured loans, the government removes the risk from banks and investors, making it much easier to get loans whether you are a foreigner or a Canadian. A foreigner with a good credit rating can invest in Canadian real estate, borrow money from the Canadian government to invest in our own housing market... and if anything goes wrong they're not Canadian and don't have to face any financial responsibility here. If everything goes smoothly for the duration they eventually withdraw their money (with a decent profit) and put it to use elsewhere.
Having such weak policies and lending standards is Canada's Achilles heel.
A report from the Reason Foundation in the USA found that government guarantees always underprice risk, drive mortgage investment into unsafe markets and inflate housing prices by distorting the allocation of capital. Governments simply cannot price risk accurately while banks and private lenders have every incentive to price risk appropriately because its their money on the line. If the government loses money its the taxpayer that ends up with burdened and governments are far too willing to take unnecessary risks when there is no incentive to insure success.
If we were to try to prevent an American-style housing bubble bursting we should not have the Canadian government guaranteeing mortgages. Let the banking industry put the money up themselves and take on the risk.
After all why should taxpayers be asked to take on the risks of bankers and foreign investors? If people want to invest in Canada, fine, but they should do so without using government money as collateral.
The USA is already starting down that path. People looking to get a home purchase loan are now looking at companies which guarantee their own mortgages. ie. Mortgage Solutions of Colorado and similar companies are reducing (or removing entirely) their dependence on government guarantees.
Part of it may be because companies have realized that the American government isn't going to guarantee mortgages willy-nilly any more. Another part of it is Americans have become much more scared of mortgage contracts signed during a bubble and they think it is less risky to deal with a company which has its own money and isn't borrowing against itself to prop up its business.
Sadly I don't think Canada will learn from the USA's mistakes. We are just going to repeat the problem.
Advertising Amenities Architecture Bizarre and Interesting Real Estate Commercial Real Estate Condo Sales and Prices Construction Credit Dream Home Economics Electricity and Alternative Energy Flipping Properties Gardening Glossary Home Insurance Home Related Home Sales House Prices Housing Starts Interest Rates Landscaping Legal Issues Montreal Real Estate Mortgages Moving Notes Off Grid Homes Ontario Overseas Real Estate Parking Plumbing QUEST FOR A CONDO Real Estate Brokers Real Estate Bubbles Real Estate History Real Estate Humour Real Estate Investment Real Estate Quotes Renovations Renting Taxes The Home Office Toronto Real Estate Trends Urban Planning US Real Estate Vancouver Real Estate
Okay, maybe not worth dying for. After all if you're dead, you can't enjoy the beauty of these interesting and inspired kitchen desi...
If you've been following MY QUEST FOR A CONDO then you know I am trying to trade up and eventually get a condo in Toronto... via tradin...
The photo you are looking at above is a Google Street View photo of Antoine Berthelet Avenue in Montreal. The reason why is because th...
Did you know Toronto is one of the most expensive places to rent an apartment? In Toronto the average price of a two-bedroom apartment is $1...
CANADA - Looking to buy a cottage in Muskoka this summer? Good luck with that! (sarcasm) The cottage prices in the region are sky high (ie....
The Bank of Canada has raised interest rates again, making it more difficult for people to get a mortgage at an affordable rate. The key ove...
I was looking for something else when I found this artist's rendering of an architectural piece that looks like a King Cobra. I though...
Kyle MacDonald is a Canadian Blogger who created a website called "One Red Paperclip". What he did was barter and trade his 1 re...
Some people who are superstitious would prefer to avoid a house with a history... ie. its supposedly haunted. Wooooooooo... spooky! Others...
Whether you are building your dream home or looking to flip a house for a handsome profit, polished concrete is the way to go. I first s...